deviant ART

[x]

Critique: How to

Journal Entry: Tue Nov 6, 2007, 12:41 PM
  • Mood: Artistic
  • Reading: comments on this (pleeease :3 )
Hello there! This is a collection of tutorials and tips as to how to comment and make critiques n_n Please take your time to browse through them, and do your part to change those one-word comments. Comments are supposed to be useful! n___n This is in no specific order, by the way ^^; This is what I could find searching around the internet. If there is anything you would like me to add here, please say it and I'll be happy to do so n_n

Give your opinion on this and help spread the word!

Wikipedia (definition of critic) => [link]
********************************************************

Pro-critique iniciatives by deviants:


=> "The Critique Bug" ([link]) by the great :iconsino:

=> A watch AND critique orgie here [link] by :iconabfc:

=> A critique service on dAmn by :icondepresedescapist: (see the journal here [link])

=> The Commenter's Project [link] by :iconvachi-bumbernickle:

=> Crit-for-Tat [link] by :iconsimeberg:

=> A very good proposal of compromise [link] by :iconcozmictwinkie:

=> A very usefull entry [link] by :iconlovetodeviate: be sure to check it regulary!

=> Secret Senior: Edition One [link] is a great place to look at great critiques and learn from them, as well as a very good idea itself!

=> Criticism - forum thread [link] by :iconnisshu-chan:

=> Your own worst critic? Why? - forum thread [link] by :iconhakubaikou:

* TUTORIALS

1) General

Tutorial : How to leave a comment => [link] by :icontreijim:

Giving a Critique => [link] by :iconliiga:

Helpful Tips on Criticing => [link] by :iconarafel:

How to to give a critique => [link] by :iconlilmissmaya:

A good Critique => [link] by by :iconlifeswaitingtobegin:

Commenting well => [link] by :iconmisskittyoooo:

Deviant Guide: Good Comments => [link] by :iconbringbackart:

Critique and good comments => [link] by :iconlivana-deathrose:

Tips to Critique on DA => [link] by :icongoblinqueeen:

How To Give Better Comment => [link] by :iconleodadominico:

CRITIQUE => [link] by :icontangledweb:

critique tutorial => [link] by :iconheartofglitter:

Positive Critique Guide => [link] by :iconemotive-box:

The Critique CheatSheet => [link] by :iconprocritique:

The Art of Critique => [link] by :iconthehalcyon:

The Art Critiquing Process => [link]

FARP : How to Give Criticism => [link]

Taking a critique => [link] by :iconliiga:

Deviant Guide: Good Responses => [link] by :iconbringbackart:

FARP : How to Accept Criticism => [link]




2) Gallery specific


A Verbose Guide to Critiquing => [link] by :iconmavyrk:

The Delicate Art of (Web) Design Critique => [link]

Successful Art Class Critique (Teacher Instructions for Critique Response Form for Art Students) => [link]

Art Commentary Tutorial => [link] by :iconosandstorrm:

ArtsEdge - Teaching Students to Critique => [link]

Critique Standards => [link] by :iconprocritique:

The Meaningful Critique: Responding to Art from Preschool to Postmodernism (download the pdf file) => [link]

Art elements and principles => [link] by :iconartistshospital:

ULTIMATE Photography Critique => [link] by :icondoubtful-della:

A great place to learn about poetry and how to criticize it => :iconpoeticks:

A Positive Critique => [link] by :iconproseplease:

A Guide to Positive Critiques => [link] by :iconpoetryplease:

Critique Guidelines => [link] by :iconwecritique:

Accepting Critique => [link] by :iconwritersarchives:

The Writing Center - Critiques => [link]

A Guide to Good Critique - Lit => [link] by :iconlovetodeviate:


* CLUBS


:iconthephotocritic: :iconartcritiqueclub: :iconcritiqueme: :iconprocritique: :iconcritique-central: :iconwecritique:


* WHERE TO FIND HELP


:iconartistshospital: :iconsai-manga-tuts: :iconpainters: :iconda-wip: :iconthepencilclub: :iconphotoshop-tutorials: :icontipsandtricks:

Stamps

=> Critique me...I don't sue [link] by :iconcurious-nox:

=> Advanced Crit Stamp [link] by :iconmynti:

=> I Support Critiques Stamp [link] by :iconbackalleyscrapper:

=> Comment Stamp [link] by :iconwaywaterside:

=> I support Advanced Critique Stamp [link] by :iconjibrille-hillbert:

=> Support Honest Critique [link] by :iconjdipierro:

=> Critique the Art, not the artist [link] by :iconlilyflare:

=> Bring Back the Critique [link] by :iconaffinityfx:

=> Comment before you Favorite [link] and for those without subscription :iconcommentplz: both by :iconboffinbrain:

=> Kawaii isn't Advanced Critic [link] by :iconnetbug009:

=> Crit-for-Tat [link] by :iconretrozombie:

=> Crit me plz or I Welcome Constructive Criticism [link] by :iconchanny:

=> I'm a genuine Critique Whore [link] by :icontwinenigma:

=> I Support Honest Critique [link] by :iconamericanlink:

* FOR YOU TO READ AND THINK ABOUT IT (don't take them too seriously!! n_n )

CRITIQUE IS DEAD => [link] by :iconnetnessie:

Guide to Being a Jackass => [link] by :iconnetnessie:

Sporenza's Guide to Writing => [link] by :iconsporenza:

Critique This => [link] by :icondreamtides:

* Not specific for art, but can help anyway:

Accepting Criticism: A Life Skill (for younger deviants ^-^) => [link]

Coping With Criticism => [link]

How to give and receive criticism => [link]

The Hamburger Method of Constructive Criticism => [link]

Giving Constructive Feedback for Dummies => [link]

Coaching with Constructive Criticism for Dummies => [link]


IMPORTANT!! THIS IS A WORK ON PROGRESS!! So...changes and such may happen, since I need to organize this better and I'll feature more stuff as I find them. Any help you guys want to give me is appreciated ^-^

Devious Comments

love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0

~LadyHisoka:iconLadyHisoka: Nov 6, 2007, 1:39:35 PM
About damed time someone listed all these off! perhaps not they will stop whining when their comments are hidden. (witch is my real big issue all along)

People keep talking to us like we are computers its degradeing!

--
Blond Uke + Bondage = Hotness :faint:

Visit my Blog [link]

-WARNING- NO Spam, flame or roastings tolerated!
~rowenabrennavart:iconrowenabrennavart: Nov 6, 2007, 2:22:01 PM
I'm glad you like it n_n If you find anything more that can be useful, let me know and I'll add! n_n

--
I am Sinistra in the deviantART Harry Potter Crew!

AIDS Walk 2007

please visit [link]
*luniara:iconluniara: Nov 6, 2007, 2:40:18 PM
There should also be a tutorial for how to ACCEPT critiques.
Hidden By Owner
*luniara:iconluniara: Nov 6, 2007, 2:40:34 PMComment hidden by Owner
This comment is hidden and not visible to general public.
*luniara:iconluniara: Nov 6, 2007, 2:45:52 PM
Were you asking me if you wanted me to post this in my journal or spread it around? which? =)

srsly, its not the critiquers. It's the people who take them. They sit and think the people critting them are picking on them. Mind you I make the mistakes of sometimes not looking at the discourage crit thing, but eh!

People stopped critting because people just want ass pats.

However, this could help.
~rowenabrennavart:iconrowenabrennavart: Nov 6, 2007, 2:53:12 PM
Spread it, even if it doesn't link to my journal. (I don't care about fame and page views, anyway xD )

Because there are people who are begging for critics! Me included xD And people who want to help those who want critiques! Me included again! xD I'm trying to help and get to them, since =Sino won't be able to do it alone, of course. n_n So, this is for both sides. Not the best list ever, but hey, I tried ^^;

--
I am Sinistra in the deviantART Harry Potter Crew!

AIDS Walk 2007

please visit [link]
Hidden By Owner
~rowenabrennavart:iconrowenabrennavart: Nov 6, 2007, 2:55:40 PMComment hidden by Owner
This comment is hidden and not visible to general public.
Hidden By Owner
~LadyHisoka:iconLadyHisoka: Nov 6, 2007, 3:42:15 PMComment hidden by Owner
This comment is hidden and not visible to general public.
Hidden By Owner
~LadyHisoka:iconLadyHisoka: Nov 6, 2007, 3:44:53 PMComment hidden by Owner
This comment is hidden and not visible to general public.